Selecting a verdict
At the end of each fact-checked article is a final verdict. There are currently five possible verdicts:
- Accurate (supported by evidence and facts; acceptable margin of error)
- Accurate as a whole (with reservations)
- Unsubstantiated (insufficient data)
- Inaccurate as a whole (with reservations)
- Inaccurate (no factual basis; unacceptable margin of error)
Verdicts 2, 3 and 4 will include an explanation in the text or summary of the text.
In addition, since our portal is intended to be educational, we will sometimes go further in explaining our verdict.
Writers are responsible for issuing the verdict of the article they pen. When in doubt, the writing team as a whole will confer and reach a verdict.
Each article, including its verdict, is validated by a scientific or medical expert, and by the people responsible for managing the portal’s new production.
This means that each article written and its verdict are subject to numerous checks before their translation and publication.
After an article has been published, we welcome additional evidence and sources that validate or disprove our verdict. When corrections are needed, we will do so in a transparent manner and directly on the portal. The corrected article will include an "errata" section to reflect the correction.